Get Fisch Frightful Mutations With Relics & Appraisal (November 2025)

Are you struggling to get those rare Fisch Frightful mutations during the Halloween event? You’re not alone! FischFright 2025 brings exclusive mutations that can transform your fishing game, but knowing exactly how to obtain them can be tricky. These special mutations, Frightful, Spooky, Haunted, and Eerie, can multiply your fish values by up to 8 times, making them incredibly valuable for both quests and profits. In this comprehensive guide, you’ll discover exactly where to find the Halloween Appraiser, how to use relics effectively, and the best strategies to maximize your chances of getting these limited-time mutations before the event ends on November 1st.

Key Takeaways

• FischFright 2025 runs from November 18 to November 1, 2025, offering exclusive Halloween mutations
• The Halloween Appraiser is located at Crook’s Hallow (coordinates: 43, 141, -11623)
• Reach Crook’s Hallow via the Flying Dutchman or Frightful Mirror
• Frightful, Spooky, and Eerie mutations multiply fish value by 6x; Haunted by 8x
• Get mutations through appraisal, relics (2000-2500 Candy), or Trick-or-Treating (0.49% chance)
• Stack Frightful and Eerie relics for maximum mutation frequency
• Haunted Rod is discontinued, appraisal is now the only method for Haunted mutation

What is FischFright 2025?

FischFright 2025 is the annual Halloween event in the popular Roblox fishing game Fisch. This spooky celebration transforms the game with Halloween-themed content, including new fish species, exclusive mutations, special NPCs, and limited-time rewards. The event takes place primarily in Crook’s Hallow, a mysterious area that appears only during this Halloween celebration.

During FischFright 2025, players can participate in special activities like Trick-or-Treating, complete witch quests, and hunt for exclusive mutations that won’t be available after November 1st. The event introduces 28 new fish species and 6 exclusive mutations: Frightful, Spooky, Haunted, Eerie, Nightmare, and Jack’s Curse. These mutations not only make your fish more valuable but also give them unique visual appearances that reflect their spooky nature.

How to Find the Halloween Appraiser in Fisch

The Halloween Appraiser is your key to unlocking Fisch Frightful mutations during the event. Unlike the regular appraiser found in Moosewood, this special NPC only appears in Crook’s Hallow during FischFright 2025. Here’s exactly how to find them:

Getting to Crook’s Hallow

You have two main options to reach Crook’s Hallow:

1. Flying Dutchman Method: Look for Flying Dutchman announcements while playing. When his ship spawns, interact with it to teleport directly to Crook’s Hallow.
2. Frightful Mirror Method: Use the Frightful Mirror item, which will transport you to the Halloween event area.

Locating the Halloween Appraiser

Once you arrive in Crook’s Hallow, follow these steps:

1. Open your Fisch GPS and navigate to coordinates: 43, 141, -11623
2. Look for the Witch NPC in the area
3. The Halloween Appraiser stands behind the Witch, beside the merchant
4. The appraiser will have a distinct Halloween-themed appearance different from the regular appraiser

How Appraisal Works

The Halloween Appraisal process works similarly to regular appraisal but with a special twist, it can grant you the exclusive FischFright mutations:

1. Walk up to the Halloween Appraiser NPC
2. Select the option “Can you appraise this fish?”
3. The NPC will quote a price based on your fish’s weight and rarity
4. If you own the Appraiser’s Luck game pass, your cost will be reduced by 25%
5. Pay the fee to have your fish appraised
6. Successfully appraised fish will show a small green dot in the bottom-left corner of their icon

The appraisal gives you a chance to roll for Frightful, Spooky, Haunted, or Eerie mutations, making it one of the most reliable methods to obtain these exclusive traits during the event.

How to Get Frightful Mutation in Fisch?

The Frightful mutation is one of the most sought-after Halloween mutations in Fisch, giving your fish a 6x value multiplier and a distinctive purple, transparent appearance. Here are the three main methods to obtain it:

Method 1: Frightful Relic (Recommended)

The most reliable way to get Frightful mutations is by using the Frightful relic on your fishing rod:

1. Purchase the Frightful Relic: Find the Flying Dutchman when he spawns in Crook’s Hallow (every 10 minutes)
2. Cost: 2,000 Candy
3. Apply to Rod: Use the relic at the Keepers Altar to enchant your rod
4. Effect: Gives a 10% chance to apply Frightful mutation to any fish you catch

Method 2: Trick-or-Treating

For players who enjoy the Halloween spirit, you can try your luck with Trick-or-Treating:

1. Visit Houses: Approach decorated houses in Crook’s Hallow
2. Trick-or-Treat: Each house can be visited every 10 minutes
3. Drop Chance: 0.49% chance to get Frightful relic
4. Patience Required: This method is time-consuming but can be rewarding

Method 3: Halloween Appraisal

The appraisal method mentioned earlier also gives you a chance to get Frightful mutations:

1. Catch Fish: Fish anywhere in Fisch during the event
2. Appraise at Halloween Appraiser: Take your fish to the special appraiser in Crook’s Hallow
3. Random Chance: Each appraisal has a chance to grant the Frightful mutation

Pro Tip: The Frightful relic method is most efficient for active fishing, while appraisal works well for fish you’ve already caught. Consider using both methods to maximize your Frightful mutation collection!

How to Get Spooky Mutation in Fisch?

The Spooky mutation is another valuable Halloween exclusive that gives your fish a 6x value multiplier with a ghostly appearance. Here’s how to add this spooky trait to your collection:

Method 1: Spooky Relic

Similar to the Frightful mutation, the most reliable method is using the Spooky relic:

1. Find the Flying Dutchman: Wait for his ship to spawn in Crook’s Hallow
2. Purchase Spooky Relic: Costs 2,500 Candy (slightly more expensive than Frightful)
3. Enchant Your Rod: Apply the relic at the Keepers Altar
4. 10% Chance: Each cast has a 10% chance to apply Spooky mutation

Method 2: Spooky Rod

If you’re lucky enough to have obtained the Spooky Rod during previous events:

1. Use Spooky Rod: This rod has built-in Spooky mutation capabilities
2. Multiple Mutations: The Spooky Rod also has chances for Frightful and Eerie mutations
3. Note: This rod is no longer obtainable, but if you have it, it’s still functional

Method 3: Trick-or-Treating

For the Halloween enthusiasts who enjoy the festive activities:

1. Visit Halloween Houses: Trick-or-Treat at houses in Crook’s Hallow
2. 0.49% Chance: Same low drop rate as other relics
3. Collect Candy: Even if you don’t get the relic, you’ll earn Candy for other purchases

Method 4: Halloween Appraisal

Don’t forget about the appraisal method:

1. Regular Fishing: Catch fish as you normally would
2. Special Appraisal: Take them to the Halloween Appraiser in Crook’s Hallow
3. Mutation Chance: Each appraisal gives you a shot at the Spooky mutation

Pro Tip: The Spooky mutation works great when combined with other mutations. Consider stacking it with Frightful or Eerie for maximum value and visual effects!

How to Get Haunted Mutation in Fisch?

The Haunted mutation is the most valuable of the Halloween mutations, offering an impressive 8x value multiplier for your fish. However, it’s also become the most challenging to obtain. Here’s what you need to know:

The Haunted Rod Situation

Important news for players: The Haunted Rod is no longer obtainable in Fisch. This special rod, which was available during previous FischFright events, has been discontinued and cannot be acquired through normal gameplay anymore. If you were lucky enough to get it during past events, it still works and can catch Haunted mutations year-round.

Current Method: Halloween Appraisal

Since the Haunted Rod is discontinued, your only option during FischFright 2025 is the appraisal method:

1. Fish as Usual: Catch any fish in Fisch during the event period
2. Visit Halloween Appraiser: Take your catch to the special appraiser in Crook’s Hallow
3. Appraise for Haunted: Each appraisal gives you a chance to roll for the Haunted mutation
4. 8x Value: Success means your fish’s value increases by 8 times!

Why Focus on Haunted?

Despite being harder to obtain, the Haunted mutation is worth the effort:

• Highest Multiplier: 8x value increase vs. 6x for other Halloween mutations
• Unique Appearance: Haunted fish have a distinctive brown, partially translucent look
• Quest Requirements: Some Halloween quests specifically require Haunted fish
• Rarity Factor: With the rod discontinued, Haunted fish will become rarer over time

Pro Tip: Since appraisal is your only option, focus on catching high-value fish before appraising them. The higher the base value, the more dramatic the 8x increase will be!

How to Get Eerie Mutation in Fisch?

The Eerie mutation is a special Halloween trait that not only gives your fish a 6x value multiplier but also works as a secondary enchantment, making it incredibly versatile for mutation stacking. Here’s how to obtain it:

Method 1: Eerie Relic (Best Option)

The Eerie relic is your most reliable path to getting Eerie mutations:

1. Locate Flying Dutchman: Wait for his ship to spawn in Crook’s Hallow
2. Purchase Eerie Relic: Costs 2,500 Candy
3. Secondary Enchantment: Unlike other relics, Eerie works as a secondary enchantment
4. Stackable: You can combine it with primary enchantments like Frightful

Method 2: Trick-or-Treating

For those who enjoy the Halloween festivities:

1. Trick-or-Treat: Visit houses in Crook’s Hallow every 10 minutes
2. 0.49% Drop Chance: Same low probability as other relics
3. Candy Bonus: You’ll earn Candy even if you don’t get the relic

Method 3: Halloween Appraisal

The reliable appraisal method also works for Eerie mutations:

1. Catch Fish: Fish anywhere during the FischFright event
2. Appraise: Take your catch to the Halloween Appraiser
3. Chance for Eerie: Each appraisal gives you a shot at this mutation

The Power of Eerie as Secondary Enchantment

What makes the Eerie mutation special is its secondary enchantment capability:

• Stack with Frightful: Combine Eerie and Frightful relics on one rod
• Increased Mutation Rate: This stacking significantly increases your chances of getting mutations
• Quest Efficiency: More mutations mean faster completion of Halloween quests
• Value Maximization: More mutated fish equals higher profits

Pro Tip: If you can afford it, get both Frightful and Eerie relics and apply them to the same rod. This combination gives you the best chance of getting multiple Halloween mutations with every cast!

Tips for Maximizing Your Mutation Success

Getting Fisch Frightful mutations requires strategy and patience. Here are the best tips to maximize your success during FischFright 2025:

Candy Farming Strategies

Since relics cost 2,000-2,500 Candy each, you’ll need an efficient Candy farming method:

1. Trick-or-Treat Route: Create a circuit of houses in Crook’s Hallow
2. Timing: Visit each house every 10 minutes (the reset timer)
3. Group Up: Play with friends to cover more houses simultaneously
4. Event Fish: Some Halloween fish can be sold for Candy at special merchants

Relic Investment Strategy

Make smart decisions about which relics to purchase:

1. Priority Order: Frightful (2,000) → Eerie (2,500) → Spooky (2,500)
2. Stacking: Frightful + Eerie gives the best mutation frequency
3. Budget: Save at least 7,000 Candy if you want all three main relics

Appraisal Optimization

Make the most of your appraisal attempts:

1. High-Value Fish: Appraise expensive fish for better returns on investment
2. Appraiser’s Luck: Consider buying this game pass to reduce appraisal costs by 25%
3. Bulk Appraisal: Appraise multiple fish at once to save time

Fishing Location Strategy

Where you fish matters during Halloween:

1. Frightful Pools: Look for special colored pools that appear during the event
2. Crook’s Hallow Waters: Fishing in the event area increases Halloween fish spawn rates
3. Weather Conditions: Some Halloween fish prefer foggy or windy weather

Pro Tip: Create a mutation tracking spreadsheet to note which fish have which mutations. This helps you avoid re-appraising fish that already have valuable mutations!

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the FischFright 2025 event duration?

FischFright 2025 runs from November 18, 2025, to November 1, 2025. This gives players exactly two weeks to obtain all the exclusive Halloween mutations before they disappear for another year. The event ends at 16:00 UTC on November 1st, so make sure to complete your mutation collection before this deadline.

Where is the Halloween Appraiser located in Fisch?

The Halloween Appraiser is located at Crook’s Hallow, specifically at coordinates 43, 141, -11623. To get there, you can either interact with the Flying Dutchman when his ship spawns or use the Frightful Mirror item. Once in Crook’s Hallow, look for the Witch NPC, the Halloween Appraiser stands behind the Witch, beside the merchant.

Can I still get the Haunted Rod in Fisch?

No, the Haunted Rod is no longer obtainable in Fisch. This special rod was only available during previous FischFright events and has been discontinued. However, if you were lucky enough to obtain it in the past, it still works and can catch Haunted mutations year-round. For everyone else, the Halloween Appraisal method during FischFright 2025 is your only chance to get Haunted mutations.

What are the drop rates for Trick-or-Treat relics?

All relics (Frightful, Spooky, and Eerie) have the same 0.49% drop rate when Trick-or-Treating at houses in Crook’s Hallow. This means you have approximately a 1 in 200 chance of getting any specific relic from each Trick-or-Treat attempt. While the odds are low, you also earn Candy with each visit, which can be used to purchase relics directly from the Flying Dutchman.

Can I stack Frightful and Eerie relics on the same rod?

Yes, you can absolutely stack Frightful and Eerie relics on the same rod! The Eerie mutation works as a secondary enchantment, which means it can be combined with primary enchantments like Frightful. This stacking is highly recommended because it significantly increases your chances of getting mutations with every cast, making it much easier to complete Halloween quests and collect valuable mutated fish.

How much do the Halloween relics cost from the Flying Dutchman?

The Flying Dutchman sells three main Halloween relics at different prices: Frightful relic costs 2,000 Candy, while both Spooky and Eerie relics cost 2,500 Candy each. If you want to purchase all three relics, you’ll need a total of 7,000 Candy. The Flying Dutchman spawns every 10 minutes in Crook’s Hallow and sells three random limited-time items each time, so you may need to wait for multiple spawns to get all the relics you want.

What’s the difference between regular appraisal and Halloween appraisal?

Regular appraisal at the Moosewood appraiser can grant most non-seasonal mutations but cannot give Halloween-specific mutations like Frightful, Spooky, Haunted, or Eerie. Halloween appraisal at the special appraiser in Crook’s Hallow is the only method (besides relics and event rods) that can grant these exclusive Halloween mutations. The cost and process are similar, but the possible mutation outcomes are completely different.

Conclusion

FischFright 2025 offers an exciting opportunity to obtain exclusive Halloween mutations that can transform your fishing experience. With the right strategies, using relics, visiting the Halloween Appraiser, and participating in Trick-or-Treating, you can collect Frightful, Spooky, Haunted, and Eerie mutations before the event ends on November 1st.

Remember that the Haunted mutation offers the highest value at 8x, while Frightful, Spooky, and Eerie each provide 6x multipliers. For maximum efficiency, consider stacking Frightful and Eerie relics on your rod to increase your mutation chances significantly.

Don’t wait until the last minute, start collecting Candy, visiting the Halloween Appraiser, and fishing in Crook’s Hallow today. These limited-time mutations won’t be available after November 1st, so make the most of FischFright 2025 while you can!

Ready to catch some spooky fish? Grab your rod, head to Crook’s Hallow, and start hunting for those rare Halloween mutations. Your collection of valuable mutated fish awaits!